v19.1 gap-closure pass complete (commit 0af70cf). Three new documents…
Decision
v19.1 gap-closure pass complete (commit 0af70cf). Three new documents (10_DOMAIN_COVERAGE_STANDARD, 11_EVALUATION_HARNESS, 12_AUTORESEARCH_BINDING) plus extensions to 03_MCP_SERVER_STANDARD § 8.3–8.7 and 04_SKILL_STANDARD § 12.1–12.6 close all five gaps I honestly identified in my confirmation response. Framework now covers: (1) content validation via domain canon + coverage audit + 5-dim senior review rubric; (2) runtime coupling via explicit session-state schema + cost pre-flight trigger detection + result-cap algorithm + idempotency replay semantics; (3) empirical measurement via paired-vs-unpaired scenario battery with statistical significance gate; (4) AutoResearch executable runner with budget enforcement + ST decision journal integration + Vault writeback; (5) reference-docs lazy loading with trigger-driven index. 17 files, ~6,784 lines across 4 commits on v19.0 branch. Zero v18.1 disruption.
Rationale
AJ’s directive was unambiguous: “close all the gaps; ensure the highest grade of expertise is demonstrated, with zero ambiguities, zero redundancies, zero technical debt.” My prior confirmation response identified exactly 5 gaps with a proposed path to close each. AJ authorized closure. Executing was a direct, tractable piece of work given the gaps were already scoped. Each new document closes its specific gap with an executable or contract-level specification — not more prose. 10_DOMAIN_COVERAGE adds machine-checkable coverage + human checkpoint; 11_EVALUATION_HARNESS converts god-grade claim into measured per-metric gap with p-value; 12_AUTORESEARCH_BINDING binds Contract § 8 YAML to a runner with budget + state persistence + decision journal + Vault outcome. The two extensions (03 § 8.3–8.7 + 04 § 12.1–12.6) add code-level runtime coupling that was implicit in the Contract Enforcer skeleton. Pristine Sweep results: Law numbering clean (only meta-references remain for Law 5/6/7), 5 ambiguity hits all legitimate (anti-pattern table meta-references), no temp-file residue, one stale cross-ref fixed in snowflake.md. Framework at this commit satisfies the v19.1 promise: structural compliance + content validation + behavioral proof + runtime specification + lazy-load economy. Residual risks: Phase-0 tooling (~18 scripts + 1 Hookify rule + 3 crons) remains unwritten — all are spec’d, none authored; AJ may still find defects on review.
Alternatives Rejected
Outcome
Pending
Related
- execute-deep-quality-audit-pass-commit-7df0512-fixing-one-p0
- execute-v190-thoroughness-pass-as-commit-6d3760e-expand-bibl
- freeze-bible-v190-as-authoritative-framework-for-all-future
- 2026-04-04-oracle-001-self-architecture-analysis
- oracle-deep-quality-audit-closure-2026-04-21-17-findings-fix
- v1911-completion-operational-skill-sync-1-added-13upstreamsy
- blue-capability-stack-hybrid-mcp-primary-ai-surface-cli-v066
- confirmed-hybrid-blue-stack-mcp-primary-ai-surface-cli-v066
- shipped-pure-observability-cost-observer-on-fivetran-mcp-opt
- snowflake-mcp-v2202-signed-at-880-honest-tools-after-r38-r40
- tableau-mcp-v601-bible-v1917-signed-pair-certified-productio
- wire-doc-review-skill-into-helix-at-3-canonical-touchpoints
- lock-r-planev-engine-api-as-shipped-in-wave-3-pass-a-pass-b
- codex-harness-plugin-agentruntimeidcodex-not-enabled-in-open
- adopt-registry-dispatch-as-a-third-architectural-pattern-r50